I think I’m typically in the minority when I say that, looking at the big picture, teachers are not, as a whole, underpaid. The national average salary for a teacher hovers around $42,000 which is hardly a fortune. In fact, one would be hard-pressed to support a family on that income alone. But adding in all the extra stipends for extra work that many teachers are known for, most teachers are hardly living in poverty conditions. Though who couldn’t use a raise, right?
A recent New York Times article spotlighted a new charter school that is developing a “dream team” of teachers. The school, set to open this fall in New York City’s Washington Heights, plans to pay its teachers $125,000 per year. My interest was piqued immediately. But as I read on, I decided that these teachers don’t stand a chance.
The teachers that are signed on for this revolutionary school experiment include a former NBA personal trainer, two Ivy League graduates, an accomplished violist, and a teacher whose supervisor actually cried when offering a recommendation, among other very qualified individuals. The eight teachers hired for this new school will teach 120 fifth graders, chosen in a lottery with preference given to low income students that don’t perform well academically. Eventually the school’s founder, expects to grow the school to 480 students.
Sounds like a great concept—give these disadvantaged kids the best teachers and they will do well, right? Wrong, I’m afraid. What the article only mentions briefly is that these teachers are “it.” With the high salary the teachers will receive, also comes a lot of extra responsibility. The school will not have an assistant principal, teacher coaches, or substitute teachers. And teachers at this school will work longer hours and more days than the typical teacher.
What is not stated is the other “extras” we are all used to that these teachers may not see. Cafeteria services, crosswalk guards, maintenance staff, a library, supplies, readily-available technology, continuing education opportunities, support staff… The list can go on forever. I wonder how this new school can be successful with great teachers but limited resources.
Sure, hiring the best and paying them what they are worth is a great, new concept. But I don’t know any teacher that can get through the day without some of these basic necessities at their disposal. It will be very interesting to see how this experimental school does.
Me? I’ll take the lower salary and enjoy some of the great benefits of teaching. Great hours, summers off, and resources available when needed.
